Seth Barnes Sep 10, 2009 8:00 PM

I want to pull the plug - is that suicide?

I wrote about Maswane's sad life in a blog last month. Today I received the news that she has died at 19 of AIDS. When she was five years old she was ...

Subscribe


I wrote about Maswane's sad life in a blog last month. Today I received the news that she has died at 19 of AIDS. When she was five years old she was raped. That's how she contracted HIV.  She was raped again when she was seven and has never once consented to sex with a man.  One of the men who raped her has died, and the other is free, he escaped to South Africa.  Her virginity as well as her life has been brutally ripped away.

Maswane lived her last years in constant pain. Morgan Mckeown wrote this blog yesterday as a testament to it. She described her visit to Maswane's bedside: "Soon after we entered she started whaling in agony, her piercing screams filled the hut.  Seeing her writhe in pain and hearing her tortured scream was heart-wrenching.  We all started to pray and she was visibly calmed, her body stopped shaking and slowly uncurled while her breath deepened again." Who can understand such pain?  I don't get it. I've tried to get my arms around it in these blogs, but my theology still falls short. And for some of you reading this, pain is an everyday reality - you know what I'm talking about. Words just seem so flimsy in the face of pain like yours. Three years ago I wrote a blog about a friend of mine who we didn't expect to live. As long as I've known him, he's had to struggle with all kinds of illness. Like Maswane, he's lived a life of perpetual pain. Through the heroic efforts of his doctors, he's survived up until tonight. But tonight he is on a breathing machine, in pain and exhausted. He just texted me, "I want to pull the plug so God can take me - is that considered suicide?" This scenario actually happened to him once before about a year ago. They pulled the plug, expecting him to die, and instead God miraculously let him breathe on his own again. The doctors didn't know what to make of it.

So, he's asking me for advice - what do I tell him? Is it OK to pull the plug?

Related Blogs

Why we need our hearts broken

Why we need our hearts broken

Have you had your heart broken lately? It's important that you do. It he...

By Seth Barnes
What responsibility do we have?

What responsibility do we have?

Pakistan is a country that many Americans consider unsafe. We know what happened...

By Seth Barnes
Working on Problems that Matter

Working on Problems that Matter

We all work on problems, but how many of them really matter? That is to say, a p...

By Seth Barnes

Related Races (3)

Southeast Asia | Semesters | January 2026

Southeast Asia | Semesters | January 2026

South Africa | Semesters | August 2026

South Africa | Semesters | August 2026

South Africa | Semesters | June 2026

South Africa | Semesters | June 2026

Next article

We all need a eulogy

Our AI generated post content for you!

Here's a suggested caption you can copy and tweak.